Caitlin (stay_please) wrote in u2,
Caitlin
stay_please
u2

  • Music:

Weekend Wrangle Follow-Up

Alrighty... in reviewing previous Weekend Wrangles, I felt the need to update on some conclusions we've come to...

Firstly, I did a poll on best cover art.
Achtung Baby was the winner, far and away, with 57 votes.
The Joshua Tree came in second, with 19 votes.
All That You Can't Leave Behind pulled in third, with 17 votes.

Poor October, Passengers, and Under a Blood Red Sky got nary a vote.


Live - Upgrade or Downgrade?
You'll remember, over consecutive weekends I asked you how live versions affected songs - whether they should never have been played live, or if they put the studio track to shame. We had some great critical disagreement, if you compare the two threads.

These songs were mentioned in BOTH threads:
Exit
Yahweh
Bullet The Blue Sky (Popmart version) (yes, you got that specific)
Stuck In A Moment...


Of course "Streets" got much praise in the 'keep it live!' thread, but someone made the argument that The Joshua Tree album is entirely overplayed in the 'never again!' thread.
Someone else praised all live versions of "The Fly", and yet another disliked just the Vertigo tour version.


Keep on wrangling.

... and I feel like I need a lasso, with the word "wrangling" in my vocabulary now. ;)
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment